Porsche Macan Forum banner
241 - 260 of 518 Posts
Porsche has long been known for having high priced service and replacement parts. Not sure why anybody is really surprised by this story

There is a substantial risk to owning a Porsche outside of warranty. The vast majority of owners will not get burned, because fortunately other than for normal maintenance, replacement parts are not often required, especially the more expensive ones.

But things like this occasionally happen. If you want to take the risk of going without a warranty, most likely you will win, but you need to recognize that this situation is within the realm of possibility.
Totally agree with you. And this is the same for all manufacturers.

But when an issue is a fairly known issue then you would expect some sort of contribution at least

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
Oh please. We are not fools here. The OP repeatedly ignored questions on how many miles were on the vehicle, and instead tried to focus on the fact that it’s only five years old. The OP admitted to the mileage only after being confronted with it. It is called “spin”.
Not sure why you are so fixated on the fact that out of my 20 posts here it wasn't until my 3rd post that I noted the mileage. I get it — you think I deserve the 20k bill for not having a warranty, for driving the car so much, and for not leading this thread off with my mileage. Noted. You're right. Hoping to move forward now. Thanks to those who've contributed to the conversation and have offered assistance.
Oh please. We are not fools here. The OP repeatedly ignored questions on how many miles were on the vehicle, and instead tried to focus on the fact that it’s only five years old. The OP admitted to the mileage only after being confronted with it. It is called “spin”.
I get it — you think I deserve the 20k bill for not having a warranty, for driving the car so much, and for not leading this thread off with a post that included my mileage. Noted. You're right. I didn't disclose my mileage until my 3rd out of 20 posts here as a way to try and "spin" this. Hoping to move forward now. Thanks to those who've contributed to the conversation and have offered assistance.
 
If you want to claim that the Macan PDK has a known issue, then at least mention how rare the issue is.

Pretty much all modern transmissions start to have a few failures at this mileage level. And it’s not unusual for those few fail failures to be focused on a couple of individual components. That is what makes it a known issue. Talk to a transmission shop, and they can pretty much tell you what typically ends up failing on any transmission they regularly service.

In this context a “known” issue does not necessarily mean one can expect to see it on their individual car. These days most transmissions end up lasting the life of the vehicle. But unfortunately a few do not.
 
Not sure why you are so fixated on the fact that out of my 20 posts here it wasn't until my 3rd post that I noted the mileage. I get it — you think I deserve the 20k bill for not having a warranty, for driving the car so much, and for not leading this thread off with my mileage. Noted. You're right. Hoping to move forward now. Thanks to those who've contributed to the conversation and have offered assistance.

I get it — you think I deserve the 20k bill for not having a warranty, for driving the car so much, and for not leading this thread off with a post that included my mileage. Noted. You're right. I didn't disclose my mileage until my 3rd out of 20 posts here as a way to try and "spin" this. Hoping to move forward now. Thanks to those who've contributed to the conversation and have offered assistance.
All I was doing was pointing out facts to someone who did not recognize them. Easy to understand why you don’t like that. I see you are throwing out the spin again. What you said on subsequent posts after you were caught purposely misleading us is irrelevant.
 
All I was doing was pointing out facts to someone who did not recognize them. Easy to understand why you don’t like that. I see you are throwing out the spin again. What you said on subsequent posts after you were caught purposely misleading us is irrelevant.
No idea why you're here trying to argue when people are genuinely trying to help. I should have noted my mileage earlier than post 3. Heard your message loud and clear. And, I agree with you. Totally my bad. It was misleading and intentional and I should have led with the mileage. I drove the car a lot — 90k is the mileage. Not sure what more you want from me, but if you feel the need to continue posting about this omission, (again — totally misleading on my part) then have at it, I guess.
 
All I was doing was pointing out facts to someone who did not recognize them. Easy to understand why you don’t like that. I see you are throwing out the spin again. What you said on subsequent posts after you were caught purposely misleading us is irrelevant.
Man, why do you have such a chip on your shoulder about this? Karma is going to get you on this one. Transmission failures at 90k aren't that normal these days and I sure as **** would be fighting for help in replacing it too.
 
Transmission failures at 90k aren't that normal these days and I sure as **** would be fighting for help in replacing it too.
Nohing to be lost in trying to get assistance, but even if they offer to pay 25 or 30% of the bill, a total replacement of the transmission is not going to make sense on a car with this much mileage. Need to look at the rebuilt alternative.

Not sure what “fighting for help“ means. What leverage does the OP have? If the car was 5000 or 10,000 miles beyond the warranty expiration I could see substantial help to the point a replacement might make financial sense. But here the car is 40,000 miles behind the warranty expiration. As I mentioned above when the transmission on our BMW went at 67,000 miles, all I could get was a polite brushoff, and and that time it was our fifth BMW from the same salesperson in 10 years. I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect to get anything meaningful from Porsche in this situation.

A transmission failure at 90,000 miles today is earlier than most today, but it’s far from unheard of unfortunately.
 
I never said forever but I would expect 200,000 + more miles at least.
Don’t disagree with the 200,000 miles, but you previously said mileage was irelevant. That’s not true. Transmissions don’t last forever. Not unusual for a car to be junked because of a transmission failure.
 
Don’t disagree with the 200,000 miles, but you previously said mileage was irelevant. That’s not true. Transmissions don’t last forever. Not unusual for a car to be junked because of a transmission failure.
For me I meant irrelevant in this case. Mainly due to age of vehicle.

Valve body seems to be the common issue when the transmission throws a fault on the cayenne and macan.

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
I have heard good things about Kachel Motors in Lawrence. I would expect they would be able to rebuild your transmission, or tell you who in the area does this type of work.
 
I own a 2015 Porsche Macan S. The car has always been maintained by my local Porsche dealer, has never been in an accident, and is in pristine condition. A month ago the engine light came on. Turns out there is a faulty transmission and the cost to repair it nearly exceeds the value of the car. My dealership has reached out to Porsche corporate, as have I, and it doesn't appear as if they will offer me any assistance due to the age of the vehicle. I was told that sometimes this "just happens." So basically they're telling me the shelf life of my Porsche is 5 years. This is my second Porsche and I thought I would always drive a Porsche. However, I would be a fool to purchase another one if they don't make this right. Does anyone know how I would sell this car? So disappointed right now. Any advice would be appreciated.
Do you have fault codes?

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
I own a 2015 Porsche Macan S. The car has always been maintained by my local Porsche dealer, has never been in an accident, and is in pristine condition. A month ago the engine light came on. Turns out there is a faulty transmission and the cost to repair it nearly exceeds the value of the car. My dealership has reached out to Porsche corporate, as have I, and it doesn't appear as if they will offer me any assistance due to the age of the vehicle. I was told that sometimes this "just happens." So basically they're telling me the shelf life of my Porsche is 5 years. This is my second Porsche and I thought I would always drive a Porsche. However, I would be a fool to purchase another one if they don't make this right. Does anyone know how I would sell this car? So disappointed right now. Any advice would be appreciated.
The gearbox in the macan is an audi dl501. The boxes seem very solid and most failures I read about are due to the solenoids failing, so much so that audi sell a repair kit.


Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
I own a 2015 Porsche Macan S. The car has always been maintained by my local Porsche dealer, has never been in an accident, and is in pristine condition. A month ago the engine light came on. Turns out there is a faulty transmission and the cost to repair it nearly exceeds the value of the car. My dealership has reached out to Porsche corporate, as have I, and it doesn't appear as if they will offer me any assistance due to the age of the vehicle. I was told that sometimes this "just happens." So basically they're telling me the shelf life of my Porsche is 5 years. This is my second Porsche and I thought I would always drive a Porsche. However, I would be a fool to purchase another one if they don't make this right. Does anyone know how I would sell this car? So disappointed right now. Any advice would be appreciated.
Just wanted to make you aware before your trousers get pulled down!!

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
My tranny needed replacing at 25k (2015 S). Chalk it up to shitty odds, replaced with refurbed unit under warranty. With no warranty and no extended warranty and 90k on the odo, don’t expect PCNA to touch this with a 10 foot poll. There’s really no reason they should, there’s no reason you shouldn’t try either, worst thing is they say “no”.
236229
 
My tranny needed replacing at 25k (2015 S). Chalk it up to shitty odds, replaced with refurbed unit under warranty. With no warranty and no extended warranty and 90k on the odo, don’t expect PCNA to touch this with a 10 foot poll. There’s really no reason they should, there’s no reason you shouldn’t try either, worst thing is they say “no”. View attachment 236229
What was the reason for the new transmission.?

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 
241 - 260 of 518 Posts