Hello All! I hope my question doesn't start a debate... 🤣 I've been on this forum for last 2+ hours searching and reading posts to try and sort out what would be the best diagnostic tool for my 2017 Macan GTS (I've also spent numerous hours comparing Autel, Launch and iCarSoft via other websites, youtube, etc.).
I would any appreciate feedback/recommendations from the experts here on which tool (make and model) would best suit my needs.
Here are the top reasons for pursuing a diagnostics tool:
1. Want to start doing my own general maintenance (oil changes, brakes, etc.).
2. Need to replace my battery soon and have read that I will need to register the new batter to the Macan.
3. Would like to do some coding for things like windows, sunroof via fob, and adjusting air suspension height.
4. Would like a unit that covers multiple manufacturers (we also have Honda and Subaru vehicles currently).
Would appreciate any feedback/recommendations (model #s would really be helpful too!!)
Thanks!
I have PIWIS, a 2021 Launch X431 Pro 3S+, and a month ago I got a 2024 Otofix D1 Max (the Otofix is built by Autel under this brand name and is aimed to the DIY market… it is cheaper than equivalent Autel, but same capabilities as it runs the full Autel software).
So, as far as capabilities:
1. PIWIS: Is a very powerful tool and will run everything you need for a Porsche, including adaptations and module programming when adding new hardware (like new headlights - which you can’t do with an aftermarket OBD scanner). But, this doesn’t address one of your requirements, which is having the ability to diagnose multiple brands.
2. Launch X431: Great tool for diagnosing faults and coding ECU. It is a hit and miss with adaptation and calibration. I downloaded Volvo and BMW as those are my other car brands… and you can download basically everything. You get 2 years of free downloads.
3. Otofix D1 Max (powered by Autel): It is very fast, great at diagnosing faults. Less intuitive for ECU coding but maybe is because I’m still learning how to get there, but relatively easy to do. It seems Otofix (Autel) uploads a backup of all your codes to the cloud before it allows you to code (after first upload, you can decide if you need to upload again or not). This is different from X431 in which you don’t need to upload your codes in order to get into coding. It’s been great with adaptation and calibration so far. I downloaded BMW and Volvo as well. With Otofix you also get 2 years of free downloads, while you get only 1 year with Autel.
In my case, I use PIWIS for serious stuff, like refilling suspension system, height calibration, installing and programming headlights, etc…
For coding, I used X431, but since I got Otofix, I’m preferentially using it for everything I’m not using PIWIS for and haven’t used X431 since I got it. Still too early to tell, but I do like Autel environment better than X431.
I just recently used Otofix to perform a full PDK calibration successfully.
I’m planning on doing a comparison video on this, but it will probably be in a few months.