I agree that folks don't need to be so salty about EVs. We should be
thankful that Porsche is building EVs, as it allows them to meet government regulations (especially ex-US) while continuing to build the ICE 911.
Read today's
Porsche Newsroom article about Macan EV testing. This vehicle is shaping up to be a Porsche that just happens to be propelled by electrons.
Re:
@grim 's stats about EVs as a percentage of cars, two things:
1. ICE cars have been on the road for 100+ years. Tesla only launched their first mass market car (Model S) a little over 10 years ago.
2. Manual transmission cars were 1.7% of the new car market last year [
Jalopnik/WSJ]. EVs were 9% of all new car sales in 2023 [
Fortune].
No one is saying automakers should kill off manual transmission cars. In fact, it's enthusiasts who are saving the manual. (I did my part by buying a 992 Carrera T with 7MT last year!) So why the hate for EVs, which are more numerous than manual transmission cars?
All the arguments against EVs because of infrastructure mirror that of smartphone adoption over the last 20 years. I had a WAP phone and later a Palm Treo on a 3G 1xRTT network. RIM BlackBerry threatened to up-end carriers' infrastructure with all their data traffic. But guess what? Carriers adapted and brought out 4G and then 5G networks. iPhone and Android rule the roost now. And hardly anyone misses their non-smartphone.
But to build off of that infrastructure argument and America specifically, unless you've traveled abroad extensively, you would think smartphones and Internet in America is fine. And then you realize 5G in Asia is 10X as fast at 1/10th the price. Guess why? Complacency with what we have installed, among carriers and consumers. The same thing is happening with payments -- no civilized country does credit card mag stripe swipe, yet I did that for gas the other night.
I foresee EV versus ICE going the same way. Let the enthusiasts keep ICE cars. I want my 911 to run forever, and I hope my son can buy a 911 someday. But let's
please move on from the "EVs won't happen!" argument, because they will regardless of what Americans think. And America will get left in the dust as other countries advance technologically. We
will figure out all the thorny problems (public charging, electrical grid, energy density). It's just a matter of time and whether Americans want to lead or follow.