Porsche Macan Forum banner

Uncomfortable Steering Wheel Grip - 2022 Macan GTS GT Steering Wheel in RaceTex

4232 Views 76 Replies 25 Participants Last post by  RoggieRog
Hello all! I've had my 2022 Macan GTS for about 6 months and am absolutely in love with it!

I've accumulated over 18,000 miles on it.

6 months.

That's not a typo.

I've done amazing things such road trip from NYC to Montana within two weeks of ownership: left NYC with 555 miles on the ODO and returning with 7,800, roundtrips rom NYC to Atlanta, as well as NYC to the panhandle of Florida, hitting up some renowned places such as Tail of the Dragon on two trips, and MANY, MANY countless spirited joyrides.

I've had plenty of Smiles Per Gallon! :)

That all said, I love the feel of my RaceTex steering wheel, but within the first two weeks of ownership, I began to feel some chafing in the gap between my thumb and forefinger from the stitching when I hold the wheel in the 3- and 9-o'clock positions, which is my goto, natural grip. (Remember the story of the Princess and the Pea? That's my sister. ;-)) Initially, I attributed this to the break in period, and then it didn't bother me for a while. Nowadays, I notice this discomfort during long drives, or spirited drives when my hands are sweaty and my grip is tighter. I recently had a loaner with leather non-GT steering wheel while my car was in for 20K maintenance, and I also drove my buddy @frankfurtnyc awesome 2017 GTS with leather GT steering wheel, and didn't notice this discomfort. In fact, I was envying the 2022 Macan S's steering wheel feel during the two days that I had it.

I then pondered this for a while and wondered if I were genuinely enjoying the grip and feel of the two leather steering wheels that I just experienced, OR was it the CHANGE that I was enjoying, similar to how a different office chair, a different sofa/couch at a friend's place, or a different mattress at a hotel/BNB feel "better"--the psychology being the "newness" of the change, more so than the actual steering wheel, office chair, sofa, etc.; kind of a FOMO, "****, maybe I should have gotten this one instead?!" phenomenon.

But I feel that it's the chafing of the stitching that's bothering this prince. I didn't choose to be this sensitive; rather, this sensitivity chose me. And it's been like this for about the last 5-7 years of my life. For context, this Ram will have revolved 4 dozen times around the sun by March 26th.

I'm considering fingerless driving gloves, but I kind of don't want to bother with putting gloves on and taking them off when I'm going out for a drive. I like the grip of the RaceTex fabric, especially as my hands get sweaty and I'm clenching the wheel hard, but the chafing from the stitching, primarily on the lefthand side is really a downer. I've thought about using pieces of adhesive "Alcantara" as bandages only around the area where I get the chafing, but feel that it may look sketchy and leave residue behind if/when I remove it. I'm considering the relatively significant expense of replacing the steering wheel with a leather one. Suncoast has replacements for $1295.00, but mine has CF trim, which complements my gear shift lever (also wrapped in RaceTex), and I don't see that as an option--does anyone know if the CF inserts can be swapped out?

I'd love to hear some thoughts and opinions as to what I can do to resolve this. My build code is in my signature.

Thanks in advance and happy driving!

P.S. Contrary to some misinformation on the internet, and in particular with respect to a particular, very opinionated, YouTube journalist with a high following, RaceTex fabric does NOT wear out the way others make it seem. Rather, it gets matted, and this is remedied by the use of a quality Alcantara cleaner and brush and restored to a like-new condition. Think of it as shampooing your hair. I'm not saying that it doesn't wear at all, because it will indeed wear as any material does, including that of a leather-wrapped steering wheel. But I can testify that the quality of Porsche's materials is top tier. I am speaking from 18,000+ miles of hard driving experience.

Vehicle Speedometer Car Motor vehicle Tachometer
Speedometer Vehicle Trip computer Odometer Motor vehicle
See less See more
2
41 - 60 of 77 Posts
I think the leather steering wheel on my Macan is the best steering wheel I ever had in any car. And I had many nice cars. The car is 7 years old and the steering wheel is still like new.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
YES!
@ RogieRog, You are holding/gripping the wheel WRONG!
That is 100% the cause of your sensitivity issue!
You do NOT need a new wheel or a wheel cover or driving gloves or anything other than a modification of your grip.

The reason for the change in expert recommendation from 10 & 2 position to 9 & 3 is airbags.
With hands in 10 & 2, when airbag in center of s. wheel goes off, it drives your forearm into your face with considerable force, probably breaking your nose.

In the 1st photo, your thumb PADS s/b in that yellow circled area.
Your thumbs should NOT be wrapped around the wheel & mostly on the inside of the wheel.

Let us know how this proper grip works for you.

FWIW, I was told, many years ago, by an advanced driving coach, that wrapping thumbs inside the wheel can result in finger/thumb breakage or even amputation during a crash. I was & still am somewhat skeptical about the amputation.
He was also against hand over hand technique during turns.
TYVM! I will give this a try!
For the OP and to understand better, this is the standard leather, multi whatever its called 95b.1 steering wheel. Refer to post 27, which is CORRECT

I was driving today and thought to see what I was doing and without thinking it was shuffle steering. I don't see why anyone would do anything else. Its the airbag. You WILL regret it if it goes off.

See the indent below. See where the steering wheel indents? Thumbs go there, NOT around the wheel. See the stitching? If your fingers or hands are on the stitching, you are doing it wrong.



Now, also look at post 27 for the CF wheel and here it is in leather. That bulge? I suspect its there cause Porsche is known for racing. Its what they "did". Thats 10 and 2 and since race cars have no airbags, if you are going faster, the bulge works. But not for normal driving. Think of it like the Le Mans start left hand key, a remnant of racing but functionally meaningless IRL. If in a timed event, I doubt anyone is worrying about an airbag going off but on the line.

See less See more
2
  • Like
Reactions: 1
For the OP and to understand better, this is the standard leather, multi whatever its called 95b.1 steering wheel. Refer to post 27, which is CORRECT

I was driving today and thought to see what I was doing and without thinking it was shuffle steering. I don't see why anyone would do anything else. Its the airbag. You WILL regret it if it goes off.

See the indent below. See where the steering wheel indents? Thumbs go there, NOT around the wheel. See the stitching? If your fingers or hands are on the stitching, you are doing it wrong.



Now, also look at post 27 for the CF wheel and here it is in leather. That bulge? I suspect its there cause Porsche is known for racing. Its what they "did". Thats 10 and 2 and since race cars have no airbags, if you are going faster, the bulge works. But not for normal driving. Think of it like the Le Mans start left hand key, a remnant of racing but functionally meaningless IRL. If in a timed event, I doubt anyone is worrying about an airbag going off but on the line.

I appreciate the time you put into a reply. I will give this a try the next time I’m behind the wheel.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Lady at work got in a crash mostly a fender bender but she had her thumbs on the inside of the steering wheel. Now her one thumb points backwards. And she doesn't drive with her thumbs inside the wheel anymore.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Ouch, that doesn't sound pleasant. Nor would having your wrist watch launched at your face at 200mph by the airbag. Especially if you wear something like a Patek Phillipe, talk about insult to injury.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I think everyone contributing to this thread should now post a pic of themselves holding their steering wheel 😁. Particularly interested in anyone using the 5 past 7 hold 🤣
  • Haha
Reactions: 1
I don't buy the 10-2 is a risk with airbags (assuming you don't have your thumbs hooked). I have yet to find any actual data that shows it is an issue. Everything I found was commenting on the thumbs being inside when at 10-2, or with hands at the top of the wheel. If you think about it, the bag is in the center of the wheel and when it explodes, it does so outward. That would push your hands/arms back and away from the wheel. If you are holding the edge of the wheel, how does the bag force your hands towards your face?! Even if the force was perpendicular to the face of the wheel, your hands are already outside the space occupied by your face. If one has their arms across the face of the wheel, that could be a big issue, though.

As for me, referencing Grim's image, the base of my thumb rests in the 'indent' and my thumb rests on the 'bulge' on the face of the wheel (pointing almost straight up). So, that is probably more like 9:30-2:30. ;)
See less See more
I don't buy the 10-2 is a risk with airbags (assuming you don't have your thumbs hooked). I have yet to find any actual data that shows it is an issue.



pictures, you were warned





pictures, you were warned

Did you read any of those?! Support nowhere to be found.

"If your hands are at the top of the wheel and an airbag deploys, there’s a good chance that your hands will be propelled backward and into your face at high velocity " ...nope, not what we are talking about.

"The National Highway and Traffic Safety Administration reports that improper placement of hands on the wheel when an airbag deploys has caused injuries such as amputation of fingers and “degloving”" ...and they don't define what improper placement is.

"If the driver's hands are at the top of the wheel when the wheel-mounted airbag deploys, they are likely to be knocked into his or her face. If they are at the bottom of the wheel, they will be sent sideways, and do no further damage." ...again, not what we are talking about.

"A driver sustains multiple fractures of the forearms and wrists driving her car with both hands over the airbag cover in a collision." ...once again, not what we are talking about.

"Two MN state troopers sustained fractured thumbs while resting their thumbs over the center airbag cover" ...starting to see a theme here? Not what we are talking about.

"A wedding ring of a female's left hand causes a large facial laceration just above the left eye while driving her vehicle with the left hand on top of the wheel." ...the theme continues.

...and then this article goes on to do an experiment that was poorly constructed. It appears that they think that if you drive at 10-2 that you must wrap your thumbs. Yet, when you drive at 9-3, you never do. But, it gets better: "Certainly drivers should avoid holding their hands in the airbag danger zone: over the top of the wheel, over the airbag cover, and on the bottom" ...say what? Where is the reference to not holding at 10-2?

The last one doesn't give any written details, but looks like once again this is about wrapping your thumbs.

Got any more that don't support the position?
See less See more
Did you read any of those?! Support nowhere to be found.

"If your hands are at the top of the wheel and an airbag deploys, there’s a good chance that your hands will be propelled backward and into your face at high velocity " ...nope, not what we are talking about.

"The National Highway and Traffic Safety Administration reports that improper placement of hands on the wheel when an airbag deploys has caused injuries such as amputation of fingers and “degloving”" ...and they don't define what improper placement is.

"If the driver's hands are at the top of the wheel when the wheel-mounted airbag deploys, they are likely to be knocked into his or her face. If they are at the bottom of the wheel, they will be sent sideways, and do no further damage." ...again, not what we are talking about.

"A driver sustains multiple fractures of the forearms and wrists driving her car with both hands over the airbag cover in a collision." ...once again, not what we are talking about.

"Two MN state troopers sustained fractured thumbs while resting their thumbs over the center airbag cover" ...starting to see a theme here? Not what we are talking about.

"A wedding ring of a female's left hand causes a large facial laceration just above the left eye while driving her vehicle with the left hand on top of the wheel." ...the theme continues.

...and then this article goes on to do an experiment that was poorly constructed. It appears that they think that if you drive at 10-2 that you must wrap your thumbs. Yet, when you drive at 9-3, you never do. But, it gets better: "Certainly drivers should avoid holding their hands in the airbag danger zone: over the top of the wheel, over the airbag cover, and on the bottom" ...say what? Where is the reference to not holding at 10-2?

The last one doesn't give any written details, but looks like once again this is about wrapping your thumbs.

Got any more that don't support the position?

Many, go to NIH, there are dozens of reports. No they don't tell you exactly where the hands were, eg



Two open forearm fractures after airbag deployment during low speed accidents - PubMed and on and on and on

but do whatever you want. Drive however you want. Ignore AAA. Ignore the NHTSA.

Ignore the Insurance Companies eg



Your car. People do whatever they want.

More


According to MSNBC, in extreme cases, fingers or hands were severed and arms broken. In more common cases, arms can be flung into faces, causing broken noses and concussions.

The Traffic Safety Administration, the Auto Club and other agencies instead recommend holding the steering wheel at the lower 9 o'clock and 3 o'clock positions.



at least in cars with airbags, the idea being that if your hands are at 10 and 2 when the airbag deploys your arms may get broken or your shoulder dislocated or your hands are propelled into your head and you suffer some other grievous injury.


AAA, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, and driving instructors teach that you should keep your hands lower, at 9 and 3 o'clock, or even lower, at 8 and 4. MSNBC says this change is partly to protect our hands and head, because if airbags go off, they're more likely to injure your hands that are higher up on the steering wheel and then slam your hands into your head. So apparently it's a "stop hitting yourself" adjustment.


10 and 2 fling arms into the A pillar or mirror
See less See more
Many, go to NIH, there are dozens of reports. No they don't tell you exactly where the hands were, eg
...and that is what I am ultimately trying to point out. There is nowhere I could find that stated 10-2 with thumbs out caused a hand to hit a face/head, or another injury that wouldn't happen with 9-3 and thumbs out. Just a bunch of FUD being spread. Mmmm, tasty. Eat all you want of it.

Edit: I did see one tidbit that has a bit of merit: "The 10 and 2 o’clock position is no longer recommended because the airbag can fling the arms into the A-pillar (the side border of the windshield) and rearview mirror." The A-pillar is no better than your left hand get sent out the window when it is at 9-3. The rearview mirror comment is interesting, but that would seem to suggest that, no, you will not hit yourself in the head...the mirror is the opposite direction.
Gross on the thumb, which seems to be what the op was doing and the point of this thread



not FUD, very clear, crossing arms while turning is bad, which is the point of shuffle turning. 10 and 2 was meant to pull down for non PS cars. Arms crossed over. No more, shuffle turn so arm not in front of the air bag

https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/qstn34
eww, different subject but the point is the same, airbag gonna hurt, dont have anything in the way

See less See more
I think at this point the OP gets the message, 10 and 2 is so 1965.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
@Chinner, think about the position of your forearms, not your hands, when in 10 & 2 as opposed to 9 & 3.

Also think about the size of the fully deployed airbag, not the size of the un-deployed airbag steering wheel cover.

It should be obvious but, when your hands are in the 9 and 3 position, your forearms are farther apart and farther away from the airbag. So, you still might be injured but, there is less likelihood than if your hands had been in the 10 & 2 position. Obviously, if you were in the middle of a hand over hand turn or were driving one-handed with your hand at the top of the wheel, the airbag damage, due to forearm and hand striking face, would be greater.
Is Race-Tex the same as what Porsche used to call Alcantara? This is what it looks like after I tried to clean and restore 15 years of gunk from a never-maintained wheel on my recently acquired 2008 Boxster. It now has the texture of the fur of a child's well-loved teddy bear.
View attachment 266235
😳
@Chinner, think about the position of your forearms, not your hands, when in 10 & 2 as opposed to 9 & 3.

Also think about the size of the fully deployed airbag, not the size of the un-deployed airbag steering wheel cover.

It should be obvious but, when your hands are in the 9 and 3 position, your forearms are farther apart and farther away from the airbag. So, you still might be injured but, there is less likelihood than if your hands had been in the 10 & 2 position. Obviously, if you were in the middle of a hand over hand turn or were driving one-handed with your hand at the top of the wheel, the airbag damage, due to forearm and hand striking face, would be greater.
Uh, no, not really IMO. It is the movement associated with starting in the wheel hub, expanding outward to its full inflated size. If inflates in towards the rim of the wheel in 'all' directions.

Was sitting in my on the way home last night thinking about this... With a straight wheel, 9-3 would result in left hand going into the door panel; 10-2 would go out the window...neither is good. The rearview mirror is actually in front of the wheel, so right hand isn't hitting that at any position.

There is a very small difference in arm position between 10-2 and 9-3....try it out. I don't see an 1" or so change being a factor in how the bag hits. As for turning, that is completely dependent on where you are in the turn (you are still grabbing a wheel that only moves in 2 dimensions that are tied together). 10-2 vs 9-3 at full lock? Ok, probably a bit of difference but your are screwed in either case at that point.

I will let this go, but people should sit in their car with the 2 positions and imagine an airbag that emanates out from the wheel hub. In a straight steering position, your hands are not coming towards your face. If one doesn't shuffle steer, there is a risk regardless of the hand position if hit while turning.
See less See more
How does one shuffle steer a Tesla with a steering yoke instead of a wheel?
How does one shuffle steer a Tesla with a steering yoke instead of a wheel?
I think you just catch fire before the airbag can get you.
the wheel seems thin in diameter but i have long fingers so its nit the most comfortable. i wish it was thicker.
41 - 60 of 77 Posts
Top